Theorylytics

Yoimiya vs Lyney

The auto-attacking firework vs. the magic trick sniper

TL;DR — Quick Pick

Pick Yoimiya if…

  • When you want to just click and win without aiming
  • In Vaporize teams with Yelan or Xingqiu
  • Against enemies that move too much for Lyney's charged shots

Pick Lyney if…

  • In Mono-Pyro teams (Bennett/Xiangling/Kazuha) for massive damage
  • Against bosses with predictable movement where you can land tricks
  • If you prefer a character with a higher mechanical skill ceiling
Verdict

Lyney has a higher damage ceiling in his specialized Mono-Pyro teams. Yoimiya is more versatile in terms of team building and much easier to pilot in general combat.

At a Glance

Yoimiya
Stat
Lyney
Normal Attacks
Primary Attack
Charged Shots
Vaporize / Overload
Team Comp
Mono-Pyro
HighWinner
Ease of Play
Moderate (Aimed)
Excellent
Single Target
ExtremeWinner
Very Low
AoE Capability
ModerateWinner
None (Needs Shield)
Interruption Res
Low (Taunt helps)
ATK / Pyro DMG
Self-Buffing
Huge Pyro DMG (Passive)Winner
LowWinner
Energy Need
Moderate

Strengths & Weaknesses

Yoimiya

Strengths
  • Strong Pyro damage
  • Versatile team options
Weaknesses
  • Requires investment
  • Best teams use limited 5-stars

Lyney

Strengths
  • Able to taunt enemies with the Grin-Malkin Hat from his Elemental Skill.
  • Grin-Malkin Hat can easily be refreshed using both Lyney's Charged Attacks and Elemental Burst.
  • Powerful Pyro DMG with a unique Pyro-focused kit.
Weaknesses
  • Can be easily staggered while aiming, so shields or Interruption RES are important.
  • While Lyney's kit is designed around Mono-Pyro gameplay, many teams now favor stronger reaction-based setups instead.

Shared Team Members

With Yoimiya

Bennett provides Yoimiya with a massive ATK boost and Pyro Resonance, which are essential for maximizing the damage of her firework-infused arrows. His healing also helps her stay healthy since she lacks built-in defensive mechanics.

With Lyney

Bennett is a mandatory teammate for Lyney, providing the ATK buffs and Pyro application needed to satisfy Lyney's 'Fiery Reign' passive. This passive increases Lyney's damage based on the number of Pyro-affected enemies and Pyro teammates in the party.

With Yoimiya

Zhongli's shield is vital for Yoimiya, as it prevents enemies from staggering her and interrupting her valuable Normal Attack sequence. The shield's RES shred further amplifies her Pyro damage, making him her best defensive support.

With Lyney

Zhongli provides the necessary interruption resistance for Lyney to safely charge his Prop Arrows without being interrupted by enemy attacks. The Jade Shield also provides a universal RES shred that helps Lyney's Pyro damage bypass enemy defenses.

Best Builds (Signature)

Yoimiya

Weapon

Thundering Pulse

Artifacts

Shimenawa's Reminiscence

Sands

ATK % or Elemental Mastery

Goblet

Pyro DMG

Circlet

CRIT Rate or CRIT DMG

Substats

CRIT Rate/DMG > ATK% > ER%

Lyney

Weapon

The First Great Magic

Artifacts

Marechaussee Hunter

Sands

ATK %

Goblet

Pyro DMG

Circlet

CRIT DMG

Substats

CRIT Rate / CRIT DMG > ATK % > Energy Recharge

Who Should You Pull?

Yoimiya
Pull Yoimiya if…
  • When you want to just click and win without aiming
  • In Vaporize teams with Yelan or Xingqiu
  • Against enemies that move too much for Lyney's charged shots
Yoimiya Full Guide
Lyney
Pull Lyney if…
  • In Mono-Pyro teams (Bennett/Xiangling/Kazuha) for massive damage
  • Against bosses with predictable movement where you can land tricks
  • If you prefer a character with a higher mechanical skill ceiling
Lyney Full Guide