Theorylytics
Dumud Gild

Ground / Water · R5

Dumud Gild

VS
Skutlass Ignis

Water / Fire · R5

Skutlass Ignis

Dumud Gild vs Skutlass Ignis

Dumud Gild vs Skutlass Ignis — two Water Pals in the Mid (R5–7) rarity band competing for the same combat slot.

TL;DR — Quick Pick

Pick Dumud Gild if…

  • You value bulk in Water fights — Dumud Gild brings 100 Defense.
  • You specifically want Golden Harvest as your combat partner skill.
  • Party buff partner skill.

Pick Skutlass Ignis if…

  • You specifically want Seared Fish Fillet as your combat partner skill.
  • Dual Water/Fire typing for coverage.
  • Skutlass Ignis's Water kit fits your party better than Dumud Gild's.
Verdict

Dumud Gild and Skutlass Ignis both cover Water DPS in the Mid (R5–7) band, but they win different fights. Dumud Gild leans on Golden Harvest and a 100 attack frame. Skutlass Ignis answers with Seared Fish Fillet and 105 attack (80 Defense vs 100). Pick the partner skill and bulk profile that match how you actually fight — not just the rarer dex number.

At a Glance

Dumud Gild
Stat
Skutlass Ignis
Ground / Water
Type
Water / Fire
R5
Rarity
R5
100
Attack
105
Winner
105
Winner
HP
70
100
Winner
Defense
80
Golden HarvestWhile in party, increases amount of Gold Coin dropped by enemies by +(100~200)% . Sometimes drops High Quality Pal Oil when assigned to Ranch , with a small chance to drop Gold Coin . (Does not stack)
Partner Skill
Seared Fish FilletWhen activated, Skutlass Ignis becomes the player's katana (Attack: (2900~4200) ). If it does not revert to its normal form quickly, Skutlass Ignis will become incapacitated. It will also become incapacitated if Iaigiri is used.
None
Exclusive Skill
None
Rocky Impact600 Power
Top Skill Power
Fire Ball600 Power
Farming · Mining · Watering · TransportingLv4 · Lv2 · Lv2 · Lv1
Work Skills
Kindling · Lumbering · Gathering · WateringLv3 · Lv3 · Lv2 · Lv2
Winner
Yes
Ride / Mount
No
3
Winner
Food Upkeep
5

Strengths & Weaknesses

Dumud Gild

Strengths

  • Top-tier Farming (Lv4)
  • Flexible base helper — 4 work roles
  • Party buff partner skill

Weaknesses

  • Better as a specialist than a do-everything pick

Skutlass Ignis

Strengths

  • Flexible base helper — 4 work roles
  • Dual Water/Fire typing for coverage

Weaknesses

  • Food 5 — plan ranch capacity

Combat Kit

Dumud Gild

Partner Skill

Golden Harvest

While in party, increases amount of Gold Coin dropped by enemies by +(100~200)% . Sometimes drops High Quality Pal Oil when assigned to Ranch , with a small chance to drop Gold Coin . (Does not stack)

Active Skills

Skutlass Ignis

Partner Skill

Seared Fish Fillet

When activated, Skutlass Ignis becomes the player's katana (Attack: (2900~4200) ). If it does not revert to its normal form quickly, Skutlass Ignis will become incapacitated. It will also become incapacitated if Iaigiri is used.

Active Skills

Work Skills

Dumud Gild vs Skutlass Ignis on shared work types — sort a column to see who wins the base slot.

Pal
Dumud Gild#109B
2
2
1
4
—
—
—
Skutlass Ignis#128B
2
—
—
—
3
2
3

Who Should You Use?

Dumud Gild
Use Dumud Gild if…
  • You value bulk in Water fights — Dumud Gild brings 100 Defense.
  • You specifically want Golden Harvest as your combat partner skill.
  • Party buff partner skill.
  • Lower food upkeep matters on your ranch — Dumud Gild is Food 3.
Dumud Gild Pal Page
Skutlass Ignis
Use Skutlass Ignis if…
  • You specifically want Seared Fish Fillet as your combat partner skill.
  • Dual Water/Fire typing for coverage.
  • Skutlass Ignis's Water kit fits your party better than Dumud Gild's.
Skutlass Ignis Pal Page