Theorylytics
Frostplume

Ice · R4

Frostplume

VS
Muffly

Ice · R2

Muffly

Frostplume vs Muffly

Frostplume vs Muffly — two Ice Pals in the Early (R1–4) rarity band competing for the same combat slot.

TL;DR — Quick Pick

Pick Frostplume if…

  • You value bulk in Ice fights — Frostplume brings 100 Defense.
  • You specifically want Peacock Pounce as your combat partner skill.
  • Frostplume sits at R4 in this band — stronger base rarity ceiling than Muffly.

Pick Muffly if…

  • You specifically want Fluffy Flutterer as your combat partner skill.
  • Party buff partner skill.
  • Lower food upkeep matters on your ranch — Muffly is Food 3.
Verdict

Frostplume and Muffly both cover Ice DPS in the Early (R1–4) band, but they win different fights. Frostplume leans on Peacock Pounce and a 100 attack frame. Muffly answers with Fluffy Flutterer and 100 attack (55 Defense vs 100). Pick the partner skill and bulk profile that match how you actually fight — not just the rarer dex number.

At a Glance

Frostplume
Stat
Muffly
Ice
Type
Ice
R4
Winner
Rarity
R2
100
Attack
100
110
Winner
HP
60
100
Winner
Defense
55
Peacock PounceWhile in party, Frostplume's icy aura sharpens focus, increasing the player's reload speeds by (20~50)% . (Does not stack)
Partner Skill
Fluffy FluttererWhile in party, increases the capture rate of Pals afflicted with Freeze . (Does not stack)
None
Exclusive Skill
None
Absolute Frost700 Power
Winner
Top Skill Power
Diamond Rain600 Power
Cooling · GatheringLv4 · Lv2
Winner
Work Skills
Cooling · TransportingLv2 · Lv1
No
Ride / Mount
No
5
Food Upkeep
3
Winner

Strengths & Weaknesses

Frostplume

Strengths

  • Strong Cooling worker (Lv4)

Weaknesses

  • Mono Ice typing limits elemental coverage

Muffly

Strengths

  • Cooling Lv2 base contribution
  • Party buff partner skill

Weaknesses

  • Mono Ice typing limits elemental coverage
  • Frail early-game combat stats

Combat Kit

Frostplume

Partner Skill

Peacock Pounce

While in party, Frostplume's icy aura sharpens focus, increasing the player's reload speeds by (20~50)% . (Does not stack)

Active Skills

Muffly

Partner Skill

Fluffy Flutterer

While in party, increases the capture rate of Pals afflicted with Freeze . (Does not stack)

Active Skills

Work Skills

Frostplume vs Muffly on shared work types — sort a column to see who wins the base slot.

Pal
Frostplume#114
2
4
—
Muffly#059
—
2
1

Who Should You Use?

Frostplume
Use Frostplume if…
  • You value bulk in Ice fights — Frostplume brings 100 Defense.
  • You specifically want Peacock Pounce as your combat partner skill.
  • Frostplume sits at R4 in this band — stronger base rarity ceiling than Muffly.
Frostplume Pal Page
Muffly
Use Muffly if…
  • You specifically want Fluffy Flutterer as your combat partner skill.
  • Party buff partner skill.
  • Lower food upkeep matters on your ranch — Muffly is Food 3.
Muffly Pal Page