Icelyn vs Muffly
Icelyn vs Muffly — two Ice Pals in the Early (R1–4) rarity band competing for the same combat slot.
TL;DR — Quick Pick
Pick Icelyn if…
- You want the higher raw attack frame — Icelyn hits 115 vs Muffly's 100.
- You specifically want Witch's Icy Veil as your combat partner skill.
- Icelyn sits at R4 in this band — stronger base rarity ceiling than Muffly.
Pick Muffly if…
- You specifically want Fluffy Flutterer as your combat partner skill.
- Party buff partner skill.
- Lower food upkeep matters on your ranch — Muffly is Food 3.
Icelyn and Muffly both cover Ice DPS in the Early (R1–4) band, but they win different fights. Icelyn leans on Witch's Icy Veil and a 115 attack frame. Muffly answers with Fluffy Flutterer and 100 attack (55 Defense vs 105). Pick the partner skill and bulk profile that match how you actually fight — not just the rarer dex number.
At a Glance
Strengths & Weaknesses
Icelyn
Strengths
- Strong Cooling worker (Lv5)
- Strong Handiwork worker (Lv5)
- Flexible base helper — 4 work roles
Weaknesses
- Mono Ice typing limits elemental coverage
Muffly
Strengths
- Cooling Lv2 base contribution
- Party buff partner skill
Weaknesses
- Mono Ice typing limits elemental coverage
- Frail early-game combat stats
Combat Kit
Partner Skill
Witch's Icy VeilWhen activated, Icelyn changes the player's attack type to Ice and increases Attack by (30~50)% .
Active Skills
- Lv1Ice Missile40
- Lv7Icicle Cutter80
- Lv15Iceberg120
- Lv22Crystal Breath160
- Lv30Freeze Wall200
Partner Skill
Fluffy FluttererWhile in party, increases the capture rate of Pals afflicted with Freeze . (Does not stack)
Active Skills
- Lv1Air Cannon40
- Lv7Icicle Cutter80
- Lv15Air Blade160
- Lv22Crystal Breath160
- Lv30Icicle Bullet250
Work Skills
Icelyn vs Muffly on shared work types — sort a column to see who wins the base slot.
Who Should You Use?
- You want the higher raw attack frame — Icelyn hits 115 vs Muffly's 100.
- You specifically want Witch's Icy Veil as your combat partner skill.
- Icelyn sits at R4 in this band — stronger base rarity ceiling than Muffly.
- You specifically want Fluffy Flutterer as your combat partner skill.
- Party buff partner skill.
- Lower food upkeep matters on your ranch — Muffly is Food 3.