Theorylytics

Lyleen vs Silvance

Lyleen vs Silvance — two Grass Pals in the High (R8–10) rarity band competing for the same combat slot.

TL;DR — Quick Pick

Pick Lyleen if…

  • You specifically want Harvest Goddess as your combat partner skill.
  • Lyleen sits at R9 in this band — stronger base rarity ceiling than Silvance.
  • Lower food upkeep matters on your ranch — Lyleen is Food 6.

Pick Silvance if…

  • You want the higher raw attack frame — Silvance hits 120 vs Lyleen's 110.
  • You specifically want Spore Stalwart as your combat partner skill.
  • You want access to the exclusive skill Giant Spore.
Verdict

Lyleen and Silvance both cover Grass DPS in the High (R8–10) band, but they win different fights. Lyleen leans on Harvest Goddess and a 110 attack frame. Silvance answers with Spore Stalwart and 120 attack (110 Defense vs 105). Pick the partner skill and bulk profile that match how you actually fight — not just the rarer dex number.

At a Glance

Lyleen
Stat
Silvance
Grass
Type
Grass
R9
Winner
Rarity
R8
110
Attack
120
Winner
110
HP
140
Winner
105
Defense
110
Winner
Harvest GoddessWhen activated, the queen's soothing graces greatly restore the player's HP.
Partner Skill
Spore StalwartWhile in party, when the player attacks an enemy afflicted with Ivy-Covered , the enemy explodes , dealing additional damage equal to (40~60)% of the player's attack damage. (Does not stack) Also grants immunity to the World Tree's Explosive Spores to both the player and their Pals.
None
Exclusive Skill
Giant Spore700 Power
Solar Blast150 Power
Top Skill Power
Spore Burst800 Power
Winner
Planting · Gathering · Handiwork · Medicine ProductionLv7 · Lv6 · Lv5 · Lv5
Work Skills
Medicine Production · Handiwork · Planting · Gathering · TransportingLv8 · Lv6 · Lv6 · Lv4 · Lv2
Winner
No
Ride / Mount
No
6
Winner
Food Upkeep
9

Strengths & Weaknesses

Lyleen

Strengths

  • Near-best Planting (Lv7)
  • Strong Gathering worker (Lv6)
  • Flexible base helper — 4 work roles

Weaknesses

  • Food 6 — hungrier than average workers
  • Mono Grass typing limits elemental coverage

Silvance

Strengths

  • Top-tier Medicine Production (Lv8)
  • Strong Handiwork worker (Lv6)
  • Flexible base helper — 5 work roles

Weaknesses

  • Food 9 — heavy ranch upkeep
  • Mono Grass typing limits elemental coverage

Combat Kit

Lyleen

Partner Skill

Harvest Goddess

When activated, the queen's soothing graces greatly restore the player's HP.

Active Skills

Silvance

Partner Skill

Spore Stalwart

While in party, when the player attacks an enemy afflicted with Ivy-Covered , the enemy explodes , dealing additional damage equal to (40~60)% of the player's attack damage. (Does not stack) Also grants immunity to the World Tree's Explosive Spores to both the player and their Pals.

Active Skills

Work Skills

Lyleen vs Silvance on shared work types — sort a column to see who wins the base slot.

Pal
Lyleen#186
7
5
6
5
Silvance#193
6
6
4
8
2

Who Should You Use?

Lyleen
Use Lyleen if…
  • You specifically want Harvest Goddess as your combat partner skill.
  • Lyleen sits at R9 in this band — stronger base rarity ceiling than Silvance.
  • Lower food upkeep matters on your ranch — Lyleen is Food 6.
Lyleen Pal Page
Silvance
Use Silvance if…
  • You want the higher raw attack frame — Silvance hits 120 vs Lyleen's 110.
  • You specifically want Spore Stalwart as your combat partner skill.
  • You want access to the exclusive skill Giant Spore.
Silvance Pal Page