Theorylytics

Menasting vs Selyne

Menasting vs Selyne — two Dark Pals in the High (R8–10) rarity band competing for the same combat slot.

TL;DR — Quick Pick

Pick Menasting if…

  • You value bulk in Dark fights — Menasting brings 130 Defense.
  • You specifically want Steel Scorpion as your combat partner skill.
  • Very fast mount / travel option.

Pick Selyne if…

  • You want the higher raw attack frame — Selyne hits 115 vs Menasting's 100.
  • You specifically want Celestial Darkness as your combat partner skill.
  • Lower food upkeep matters on your ranch — Selyne is Food 2.
Verdict

Menasting and Selyne both cover Dark DPS in the High (R8–10) band, but they win different fights. Menasting leans on Steel Scorpion and a 100 attack frame. Selyne answers with Celestial Darkness and 115 attack (110 Defense vs 130). Pick the partner skill and bulk profile that match how you actually fight — not just the rarer dex number.

At a Glance

Menasting
Stat
Selyne
Dark / Ground
Type
Dark / Neutral
R9
Rarity
R9
100
Attack
115
Winner
100
HP
130
Winner
130
Winner
Defense
110
Steel ScorpionWhen fighting together, increases the player's defense and Electric Pals drop more items when defeated.
Partner Skill
Celestial DarknessCan be ridden as a flying mount. While mounted, enhances Neutral and Dark attacks by (15~30)% . Technology 53
None
Exclusive Skill
None
Rock Lance150 Power
Top Skill Power
Holy Burst700 Power
Winner
Mining · LumberingLv5 · Lv3
Work Skills
Handiwork · Medicine Production · TransportingLv7 · Lv6 · Lv3
Winner
No
Ride / Mount
Yes
7
Food Upkeep
2
Winner

Strengths & Weaknesses

Menasting

Strengths

  • Strong Mining worker (Lv5)
  • Very fast mount / travel option
  • Party buff partner skill

Weaknesses

  • Food 7 — high upkeep

Selyne

Strengths

  • Near-best Handiwork (Lv7)
  • Strong Medicine Production worker (Lv6)
  • Flexible base helper — 3 work roles

Weaknesses

  • Harder to obtain than common workers

Combat Kit

Menasting

Partner Skill

Steel Scorpion

When fighting together, increases the player's defense and Electric Pals drop more items when defeated.

Active Skills

Selyne

Partner Skill

Celestial Darkness

Can be ridden as a flying mount. While mounted, enhances Neutral and Dark attacks by (15~30)% . Technology 53

Active Skills

Work Skills

Menasting vs Selyne on shared work types — sort a column to see who wins the base slot.

Pal
Menasting#099
3
5
Selyne#190
7
6
3

Who Should You Use?

Menasting
Use Menasting if…
  • You value bulk in Dark fights — Menasting brings 130 Defense.
  • You specifically want Steel Scorpion as your combat partner skill.
  • Very fast mount / travel option.
  • Party buff partner skill.
Menasting Pal Page
Selyne
Use Selyne if…
  • You want the higher raw attack frame — Selyne hits 115 vs Menasting's 100.
  • You specifically want Celestial Darkness as your combat partner skill.
  • Lower food upkeep matters on your ranch — Selyne is Food 2.
Selyne Pal Page