Theorylytics

Muffly vs Smokie Cryst

Muffly vs Smokie Cryst — two Ice Pals in the Early (R1–4) rarity band competing for the same combat slot.

TL;DR — Quick Pick

Pick Muffly if…

  • You specifically want Fluffy Flutterer as your combat partner skill.
  • Party buff partner skill.
  • Muffly's Ice kit fits your party better than Smokie Cryst's.

Pick Smokie Cryst if…

  • You value bulk in Ice fights — Smokie Cryst brings 90 Defense.
  • You specifically want Cryo Instincts as your combat partner skill.
  • Dual Dark/Ice typing for coverage.
Verdict

Muffly and Smokie Cryst both cover Ice DPS in the Early (R1–4) band, but they win different fights. Muffly leans on Fluffy Flutterer and a 100 attack frame. Smokie Cryst answers with Cryo Instincts and 100 attack (90 Defense vs 55). Pick the partner skill and bulk profile that match how you actually fight — not just the rarer dex number.

At a Glance

Muffly
Stat
Smokie Cryst
Ice
Type
Dark / Ice
R2
Rarity
R3
Winner
100
Attack
100
60
HP
85
Winner
55
Defense
90
Winner
Fluffy FluttererWhile in party, increases the capture rate of Pals afflicted with Freeze . (Does not stack)
Partner Skill
Cryo InstinctsWhile at a base, increases the Cooling Work Suitability Level for all other Base Pals by +1 . (Does not stack)
None
Exclusive Skill
None
Diamond Rain600 Power
Top Skill Power
Diamond Rain600 Power
Cooling · TransportingLv2 · Lv1
Work Skills
Cooling · GatheringLv2 · Lv2
Winner
No
Ride / Mount
No
3
Food Upkeep
3

Strengths & Weaknesses

Muffly

Strengths

  • Cooling Lv2 base contribution
  • Party buff partner skill

Weaknesses

  • Mono Ice typing limits elemental coverage
  • Frail early-game combat stats

Smokie Cryst

Strengths

  • Cooling Lv2 base contribution
  • Dual Dark/Ice typing for coverage

Weaknesses

  • Better as a specialist than a do-everything pick

Combat Kit

Muffly

Partner Skill

Fluffy Flutterer

While in party, increases the capture rate of Pals afflicted with Freeze . (Does not stack)

Active Skills

Smokie Cryst

Partner Skill

Cryo Instincts

While at a base, increases the Cooling Work Suitability Level for all other Base Pals by +1 . (Does not stack)

Work Skills

Muffly vs Smokie Cryst on shared work types — sort a column to see who wins the base slot.

Pal
Muffly#059
2
1
Smokie Cryst#149B
2
2

Who Should You Use?

Muffly
Use Muffly if…
  • You specifically want Fluffy Flutterer as your combat partner skill.
  • Party buff partner skill.
  • Muffly's Ice kit fits your party better than Smokie Cryst's.
Muffly Pal Page
Smokie Cryst
Use Smokie Cryst if…
  • You value bulk in Ice fights — Smokie Cryst brings 90 Defense.
  • You specifically want Cryo Instincts as your combat partner skill.
  • Dual Dark/Ice typing for coverage.
  • Smokie Cryst sits at R3 in this band — stronger base rarity ceiling than Muffly.
Smokie Cryst Pal Page