Theorylytics

Nitemary vs Shroomer Noct

Nitemary vs Shroomer Noct — two Dark Pals in the Mid (R5–7) rarity band competing for the same combat slot.

TL;DR — Quick Pick

Pick Nitemary if…

  • You value bulk in Dark fights — Nitemary brings 105 Defense.
  • You specifically want Soul Collector as your combat partner skill.
  • Combat-focused partner skill.

Pick Shroomer Noct if…

  • You specifically want Roiling Spores as your combat partner skill.
  • Useful as a mounted travel Pal.
  • Dual Grass/Dark typing for coverage.
Verdict

Nitemary and Shroomer Noct both cover Dark DPS in the Mid (R5–7) band, but they win different fights. Nitemary leans on Soul Collector and a 100 attack frame. Shroomer Noct answers with Roiling Spores and 100 attack (90 Defense vs 105). Pick the partner skill and bulk profile that match how you actually fight — not just the rarer dex number.

At a Glance

Nitemary
Stat
Shroomer Noct
Dark
Type
Grass / Dark
R6
Winner
Rarity
R5
100
Attack
100
105
HP
110
Winner
105
Winner
Defense
90
Soul CollectorWhile fighting together, Pals drop +(100~200)% more Pal Souls when defeated. (Does not stack)
Partner Skill
Roiling SporesCan be ridden. While at a base, its mysterious spores slow the rate at which the SAN value of allies at the base decreases by (10~15)% . Technology 39
None
Exclusive Skill
None
Dark Whisp600 Power
Top Skill Power
Dark Whisp600 Power
Handiwork · TransportingLv4 · Lv2
Work Skills
Gathering · Handiwork · Planting · LumberingLv3 · Lv3 · Lv3 · Lv2
Winner
No
Ride / Mount
Yes
6
Food Upkeep
5
Winner

Strengths & Weaknesses

Nitemary

Strengths

  • Strong Handiwork worker (Lv4)
  • Combat-focused partner skill

Weaknesses

  • Food 6 — hungrier than average workers
  • Mono Dark typing limits elemental coverage

Shroomer Noct

Strengths

  • Flexible base helper — 4 work roles
  • Useful as a mounted travel Pal
  • Dual Grass/Dark typing for coverage

Weaknesses

  • Food 5 — plan ranch capacity

Combat Kit

Nitemary

Partner Skill

Soul Collector

While fighting together, Pals drop +(100~200)% more Pal Souls when defeated. (Does not stack)

Active Skills

Shroomer Noct

Partner Skill

Roiling Spores

Can be ridden. While at a base, its mysterious spores slow the rate at which the SAN value of allies at the base decreases by (10~15)% . Technology 39

Active Skills

Work Skills

Nitemary vs Shroomer Noct on shared work types — sort a column to see who wins the base slot.

Pal
Nitemary#148
4
2
Shroomer Noct#118B
3
3
3
2

Who Should You Use?

Nitemary
Use Nitemary if…
  • You value bulk in Dark fights — Nitemary brings 105 Defense.
  • You specifically want Soul Collector as your combat partner skill.
  • Combat-focused partner skill.
  • Nitemary sits at R6 in this band — stronger base rarity ceiling than Shroomer Noct.
Nitemary Pal Page
Shroomer Noct
Use Shroomer Noct if…
  • You specifically want Roiling Spores as your combat partner skill.
  • Useful as a mounted travel Pal.
  • Dual Grass/Dark typing for coverage.
  • Lower food upkeep matters on your ranch — Shroomer Noct is Food 5.
Shroomer Noct Pal Page