Theorylytics

Arlecchino vs Hu Tao

Self-sufficient carry vs. the highest Vaporize ceiling in Pyro.

TL;DR — Quick Pick

Pick Arlecchino if…

  • You want a Pyro carry that doesn't need a shielder or dedicated healer.
  • You prefer straightforward rotations with consistent output.
  • Your roster lacks Zhongli or Layla for survivability support.

Pick Hu Tao if…

  • You already own Staff of Homa and want to maximize its value.
  • You have Zhongli, Layla, or another shielder to cover her survivability gap.
  • You enjoy HP-management gameplay and find it engaging rather than stressful.
Verdict

Both are excellent Pyro carries, but they solve different problems. Arlecchino is the safer, more flexible pick — she builds her own sustain, welcomes a wide range of supports, and performs consistently across all content. Hu Tao trades that comfort for a higher damage ceiling, particularly in Vaporize teams, but demands a dedicated shielder and careful HP management. If you're unsure, Arlecchino is the easier recommend. Pull Hu Tao if you specifically want to push her ceiling.

At a Glance

Arlecchino
Stat
Hu Tao
Polearm
Weapon
Polearm
5★
Rarity
5★
On-field Normal ATKWinner
Playstyle
Charged ATK + HP Mgmt
Yes (Burst heal)Winner
Self-sustain
No (needs Zhongli)
HighWinner
Team flexibility
Moderate
High
Vaporize ceiling
HigherWinner
Easy–ModerateWinner
Difficulty
Moderate–Hard
Crimson Moon's Semblance
Signature weapon
Staff of Homa
Good (Deathmatch)Winner
F2P viability
Moderate (Dragon's Bane)
Excellent
C0 performance
Excellent

Strengths & Weaknesses

Arlecchino

Strengths
  • High personal damage that isn’t reliant on specific combos
  • Flexible teambuilding and rotations
  • Not reliant on her Burst to deal damage
Weaknesses
  • Cannot rely on healers for survivability; personal healing is tied to a fairly high-cost Burst
  • Vulnerable to interruption at C0
  • Noticeable performance gap between her signature weapon and other weapons, particularly free ones

Hu Tao

Strengths
  • Strong Pyro damage
  • Versatile team options
Weaknesses
  • Requires investment
  • Best teams use limited 5-stars

Shared Team Members

With Arlecchino

Core pick. Unmatched flat ATK buff, Pyro resonance, and emergency healing that keeps Bond of Life HP management comfortable.

With Hu Tao

Essential. His ATK buff amplifies every Charged Attack and his healing means Hu Tao doesn't need to manage survivability through Zhongli alone.

With Arlecchino

Solid Vaporize enabler. Consistent off-field Hydro and a stacking DMG Bonus. Slightly weaker than Furina for Arlecchino specifically.

With Hu Tao

Strong single-target Vaporize partner. Her DMG Bonus ramp is valuable in longer rotations where Hu Tao can sustain Charged Attacks.

With Arlecchino

Excellent pairing. Arlecchino's Bond of Life HP movement triggers Furina's passive constantly, giving near-permanent stacks of her DMG Bonus.

With Hu Tao

Strong but requires careful HP management. Furina's healing drain combined with Hu Tao's low-HP requirement can be tricky without a shielder.

With Arlecchino

Essentially mandatory in Vaporize comps. His Pyro shred and EM-scaling DMG Bonus make him one of Arlecchino's most consistent support picks.

With Hu Tao

Excellent in Vaporize. VV shred amplifies Hu Tao's Pyro damage and his DMG Bonus scales with his own EM — a clean pairing in reaction teams.

Best Builds (Signature)

Arlecchino

Weapon

Crimson Moon's Semblance

Artifacts

Fragment of Harmonic Whimsy

Sands

HP%

Goblet

Pyro DMG%

Circlet

CRIT DMG

Substats

CRIT DMG ≥ CRIT Rate > HP% > ATK%

Hu Tao

Weapon

Staff of Homa

Artifacts

Crimson Witch of Flames

Sands

ATK%

Goblet

DMG%

Circlet

CRIT Rate

Substats

CRIT Rate/DMG > ATK% > ER%

Who Should You Pull?

Arlecchino
Pull Arlecchino if…
  • You want a Pyro carry that doesn't need a shielder or dedicated healer.
  • You prefer straightforward rotations with consistent output.
  • Your roster lacks Zhongli or Layla for survivability support.
  • You play a lot of Overworld where survivability matters more than peak DPS.
  • You want strong F2P weapon options (Deathmatch performs well).
Arlecchino Full Guide
Hu Tao
Pull Hu Tao if…
  • You already own Staff of Homa and want to maximize its value.
  • You have Zhongli, Layla, or another shielder to cover her survivability gap.
  • You enjoy HP-management gameplay and find it engaging rather than stressful.
  • You want the highest single-target Vaporize ceiling in the Pyro roster.
  • You prefer Charged Attack playstyles over Normal Attack combos.
Hu Tao Full Guide