Theorylytics

Lucy vs Nicole

Lucy vs Nicole — two Support agents competing for the same roster slot.

TL;DR — Quick Pick

Pick Lucy if…

  • You need a Fire Support agent and Lucy's kit matches your account gap.
  • You prefer Support gameplay over Nicole's Support identity.
  • Lucy is a premier support unit who provides significant team-wide ATK buffs through her guard boars.

Pick Nicole if…

  • You need a Ether Support agent and Nicole's kit matches your account gap.
  • You prefer Support gameplay over Lucy's Support identity.
  • Nicole is an essential A-rank support who provides invaluable utility through heavy DEF shred and Ether DMG amplification.
Verdict

Lucy and Nicole are both Support investments that answer different account needs. Lucy (Fire, Support) shines when Lucy is a premier support unit who provides significant team-wide ATK buffs through her guard boars. Nicole (Ether, Support) is the better commit when Nicole is an essential A-rank support who provides invaluable utility through heavy DEF shred and Ether DMG amplification. Compare signature builds, team requirements, and your existing supports before pulling either.

At a Glance

Lucy
Stat
Nicole
Fire
Attribute
Ether
Support
Specialty
Support
A-Rank
Rank
A-Rank
Support
Primary role
Support
Buffs / Utility
Damage type
Buffs / Utility
ATK% (top priority until ability cap)
Scaling focus
Anomaly Proficiency
Support + Fire
Playstyle clarity
Ether + Support
StrongWinner
Self-sustain
Moderate
ModerateWinner
Team flexibility
Focused
Zhao
Best support shell
Nangong Yu / Astra Yao
Slice of Time — A-rank · AccessibleWinner
F2P W-Engine path
Slice of Time(S5) — A-rank · Accessible
Excellent
M0 viability
Excellent

Strengths & Weaknesses

Lucy

Strengths
  • Provides significant flat and percentage ATK buffs to the team.
  • Guard boars inherit stats for meaningful off-field damage contribution.
  • Easy activation of Cheer On! status via EX Special.
Weaknesses
  • Buff effectiveness is capped, limiting hyper-investment returns.
  • Relies heavily on energy regeneration to maintain buff uptime.
  • Requires specific team compositions to maximize Additional Ability passives.

Nicole

Strengths
  • High DEF shred debuff
  • Effective crowd control pulling enemies
  • Strong Ether damage amplification
Weaknesses
  • Requires active reloading to maintain peak utility
  • Defensive capabilities rely on perfect dodge timing
  • Energy management is critical for field uptime

Shared Team Members

With Lucy

Secondary Anomaly / Disorder partner that amplifies Lucy's damage windows.

With Nicole

Secondary Anomaly / Disorder partner that amplifies Nicole's damage windows.

Best Builds (Signature)

Lucy

W-Engine

Kaboom the Cannon

Disk Set

Moonlight Lullaby

Disk 4

ATK% > CRIT Rate%

Disk 5

ATK%

Disk 6

Energy Regen = ATK%

Substats

ATK% (top priority until ability cap) = CRIT RATE = CRIT DMG > PEN = ATK

Nicole

W-Engine

The Vault(S5)

Disk Set

Moonlight Lullaby(4-PC)

Disk 4

ATK% = Anomaly Proficiency

Disk 5

Ether DMG% > ATK%

Disk 6

Energy Regen = ATK%

Substats

Anomaly Proficiency = ATK% > PEN = FLAT ATK

Who Should You Pull?

Lucy
Pull Lucy if…
  • You need a Fire Support agent and Lucy's kit matches your account gap.
  • You prefer Support gameplay over Nicole's Support identity.
  • Lucy is a premier support unit who provides significant team-wide ATK buffs through her guard boars.
  • Her ability to maintain high uptime on offensive support makes her an essential asset for any Fire or faction-synergized composition.
  • Lucy is a stronger general pull priority (YES) for your roster.
Lucy Full Guide
Nicole
Pull Nicole if…
  • You need a Ether Support agent and Nicole's kit matches your account gap.
  • You prefer Support gameplay over Lucy's Support identity.
  • Nicole is an essential A-rank support who provides invaluable utility through heavy DEF shred and Ether DMG amplification.
  • Her ability to group enemies while enabling massive team damage makes her a staple for any account running Ether-based squads.
  • Nicole is a stronger general pull priority (YES) for your roster.
Nicole Full Guide